Sudoku Desk

W-Wing

Two identical pairs joined by a strong link.

Very Hard

A W-Wing uses two cells with the same two candidates, say {4,8}, that don’t see each other. On their own they prove nothing. But if they are connected by a strong link on one of the digits — a row, column or box where that digit has only two spots, one seeing each cell — something useful follows.

The two cells can’t both be the linked digit, so at least one of them is the other digit.

The rule

Two cells {X,Y} joined by a strong link on X: remove Y from every cell that sees both of them.

How to spot it

  1. Find two bivalue cells with the same pair, e.g. {4,8}, that are not in the same house.
  2. Look for a house where 4 has exactly two candidates, one seeing each of the two cells.
  3. Remove 8 from every cell that sees both {4,8} cells.

Why it works

The linking house must have its 4 in one of its two spots, and each spot sees one of the pair cells. So at least one pair cell can’t be 4 — it must be 8. A cell that sees both pair cells therefore sees an 8 for sure.

When to look for it

Look for W-Wings when the grid has many bivalue cells (cells with exactly two candidates). Scan for any pair that appears twice in cells that don’t see each other, then check both digits for a strong link that connects them.

Example from a real puzzle

This position comes from one of Sudoku Desk’s Very Hard daily puzzles, at the moment the W-Wing is the next logical step. Small grey digits are the remaining candidates.

W-Wing example 1C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R92946138578654271937315895864216545273937216948545459732616532759189173865244528945137644884488
  • Pattern
  • Other candidate
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. R4C2 and R6C6 are both {4,8}, and the only two spots for 4 in their connecting house are R7C2 and R7C6.
  2. That link means R4C2 and R6C6 can’t both be 4 — so at least one of them is 8.
  3. Any cell that sees both R4C2 and R6C6 therefore can’t be 8: R4C4, R6C2.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the W-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

Another example

The same pattern in a different Very Hard puzzle, this time with digit 5. Try to spot it before reading the steps.

W-Wing example 2C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R954123678938914762572695813467489213293257615948491832596724934512458768526723911678934524455445
  • Pattern
  • Other candidate
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. R4C3 and R6C6 are both {4,5}, and the only two spots for 4 in their connecting house are R8C3 and R8C6.
  2. That link means R4C3 and R6C6 can’t both be 4 — so at least one of them is 5.
  3. Any cell that sees both R4C3 and R6C6 therefore can’t be 5: R4C4.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the W-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

One more example

The same pattern in a different Very Hard puzzle, this time with digit 6. Try to spot it before reading the steps.

W-Wing example 3C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R9314814752975981623462146314975893258167447592618368173459216429783589753426523146146891671166116
  • Pattern
  • Other candidate
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. R1C8 and R8C4 are both {1,6}, and the only two spots for 1 in their connecting house are R2C9 and R8C9.
  2. That link means R1C8 and R8C4 can’t both be 1 — so at least one of them is 6.
  3. Any cell that sees both R1C8 and R8C4 therefore can’t be 6: R1C4.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the W-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

Practise it

Your turn. Each puzzle below has a W-Wing waiting to be found. Tap the cell, pick the candidate it removes, and you’ll see straight away if you’re right. Stuck? Take a hint.

Tips

  • W-Wings are easy to miss because the two pair cells are far apart. Scan for repeated pairs across the whole grid.

Common mistakes

  • Using two pair cells that see each other – that’s a Naked Pair, not a W-Wing.
  • Removing the linked digit instead of the other one. With a {4,8} pair and a strong link on 4, it’s the 8 that goes.
  • Using a “link” house where the digit has three or more candidates. It must have exactly two spots, one seeing each pair cell.
  • Letting an end of the strong link be one of the pair cells. The link’s ends must be separate cells that each see one pair cell.
Practise it. W-Wing shows up in Very Hard puzzles and harder. Every day there are five new puzzles — the same for everyone.
Play today’s Very Hard puzzle

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a W-Wing and an XY-Wing?

An XY-Wing uses three bivalue cells with three different pairs — a pivot and two pincers. A W-Wing uses only two bivalue cells with the same pair, and replaces the pivot with a strong link (a row, column or box where one of the two digits has exactly two spots).

Which digit does the W-Wing remove?

The digit that is not used by the strong link. If the pair is {4,8} and the strong link is on 4, then 8 is removed from cells that see both pair cells.

Can the two pair cells see each other?

No. If they shared a row, column or box they would simply be a Naked Pair. The W-Wing is useful precisely because the two cells are far apart.

How hard is the W-Wing?

Sudoku Desk rates it Very Hard. The pattern itself is short, but the two cells are usually far apart, which makes it easy to miss.

Related techniques

XY-Wing (Y-Wing)SkyscraperTwo-String Kite